Manuscript Review Form
Reviewer's E-mail:
Reviewer's Name:
Article Title
1. Introduction to the Article
Article Introduction
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments
2. Methods Section:
Research Studies Only
A. Sample:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
B. Instruments:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
C. Procedures:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments
:
D. Design:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
E. Statistics/Analysis:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
3. Results/Discussion:
Research Studies Only
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
4. Non-Research Manuscripts
A Pertinent literature review:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
B. Literature review organized and focused:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
C. Research reviewed and critiqued in article:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
D. Conclusions drawn logically:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
E. Practical implications drawn:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
F. Directions for research noted:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
5. Active Elements: Hyperlinks, graphics, slide presentation, audio, video elements
Hyperlinks:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
N/A
Graphics, charts, tables:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
N/A
Slide presentations:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
N/A
Audio:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
N/A
Video:
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
N/A
Comments:
6. Writing Style, Grammar, APA format
Acceptable
Uncertain
Unacceptable
Comments:
7. Written Feedback to Authors
8. Recommendation for Disposal
Accept as is
Accept after modifications
Revisions and review
Rewrite, resubmit and review
Reject - unsound
Reject - inappropriate for JTC; the following journals are suggested:
Last Updated:
6/20/12
